Fediverse defederation considerations - Seirdy


What I consider: Is an offending post a property of the instance or the user? It may reflect the instance if it’s written or reblogged by a staff member or part



Onion Details



Page Clicks: 0

First Seen: 03/11/2024

Last Indexed: 10/21/2024

Domain Index Total: 190



Onion Content



What I consider: Is an offending post a property of the instance or the user? It may reflect the instance if it’s written or reblogged by a staff member or part of a large pattern. If it’s a property of the user but reporting doesn’t work, do I have the spoons to moderate their instance on a user-by-case basis? I usually do this only if there are existing connections or if the instance is run by and for marginalized groups. If I see slur usage: is there plausible deniability for the slurs to be used in a reclaimed context, or for the users in question to not be native speakers? Glossing over this once earned a subsection in my blocklists’ “Mistakes Made” section . If there’s harassment, I might want to check in with the victim to see if it’s okay to save a receipt featuring them and if I should make a callout. Do staff members run other instances? I could treat all their instances collectively. Minor factors that do not directly inform the decision to defederate, but do inform the decision to look deeper before dismissing the instance: Is the instance staff close to sufficiently bad actors? If so, the staff members almost certainly post similar content. It’s worth the extra time to find the receipts. If the instance is brand-new, I might re-visit it in a week or two to see if it cleaned up. Steps I perform: Save receipts with multiple archiving services. Sometimes one service doesn’t render an archive properly, so it’s good to have alternatives. Describe reasons with those links, and make it detailed enough for readers to understand the reason without visiting any links. Archived links are for proof more than understanding. I don’t consider whether the domain is still alive, assuming I have receipts saved from when it was online. Dead instances do sometimes come back, and blocking dead instances is harmless.